The Science of Nightmares: Why We Dream of Fear | Dream Essays

Being chased, falling, trying to scream and making no sound. You wake, but your heart is still inside the dream. Everyone knows nightmares, yet few of us stop to ask why they happen. This column walks through what is reasonably established: REM sleep and the brain's alarm system, dreaming as rehearsal for danger, the night's work of processing emotion, and the links to stress, fever, medication and alcohol. At the end, we offer our own view on why people who love horror stories may have a particular relationship with bad dreams.

Nightmares Are Born in REM Sleep

Sleep alternates between non-REM sleep, when body and brain rest deeply, and REM sleep, when the body goes slack but the brain is highly active. REM stands for rapid eye movement, the flicker of the eyes beneath closed lids. Vivid, story-like, emotional dreams are thought to come mostly from REM sleep, and because REM periods lengthen toward morning, it fits that people so often jolt awake from nightmares in the hours before dawn.

During REM sleep, the amygdala, a small region tied to emotion and especially to fear, becomes very active, while parts of the frontal lobe that help us reason calmly are thought to quiet down. In a dream, then, the alarm rings easily but the brake that says this makes no sense, it must be a dream, works poorly. This combination is often used to explain why we accept absurd plots without question while the fear keeps swelling.

The body is also held still in REM sleep, with muscles relaxed so we do not act out what we dream. Some suggest this is why dreams so often feature legs that will not run or a voice that will not come. When this mechanism slips out of sync at the edge of waking, a person may be conscious yet unable to move, the experience known in Japan as kanashibari, or sleep paralysis.

How People Once Understood Nightmares

The mare in nightmare is said to preserve the name of a creature that sat on sleepers' chests (we look at those chest-sitting demons more closely in our column on sleep paralysis). What matters here is that people long ago seem to have treated bad dreams not as something rising from within, but as something that arrives from outside. Demons, ghosts, restless spirits: the names differed, but a frightening dream was thought to be carried in while one slept, which is likely why so many places developed charms to guard the pillow.

Many cultures also treated dreams as omens or messages. Customs like telling a bad dream to someone so it would pass, or cancelling it with a charm, were a kind of wisdom for undoing a frightening dream. It seems possible that people long ago, without knowing the mechanism, understood from experience that an untended nightmare lingers in the mind, and so found ways to put dreams into words and close them with ritual. That idea quietly echoes modern dream journals and imagery rehearsal therapy.

A handy pair for getting a closer look at a distant view or a dim, hard-to-see spot.

Ruxis Binoculars

VIEW ON AMAZON VIEW ON RAKUTEN VIEW ON YAHOO!

We may earn a referral fee on purchases made through these links.

Threat Simulation: Is a Dream a Rehearsal for Danger?

Why would the brain bother to build frightening scenes? In 2000, the Finnish psychologist Antti Revonsuo proposed the threat simulation theory, an evolutionary answer. Dreams, in this view, are a virtual training ground where we face danger again and again in safety, a rehearsal that may have helped our ancestors survive. It fits well with how often people around the world report dreams of being chased, attacked or falling.

This remains one hypothesis, not a final verdict on what dreams are for. Many dreams are not frightening at all, and whether rehearsal truly helps is hard to test. Still, the idea offers a kind of comfort: a nightmare may not be the product of a broken mind, but an ancient protective system working a little too hard in the middle of the night.

It is also striking that the threats in dreams are not only the old ones, like wild beasts or cliffs. Modern dreams are full of social dangers: being late for an exam, failing in public, losing something important. From danger to life to the danger of losing one's place. The threats our dreams rehearse may have changed with the times. This is only speculation, but looking at who the enemies are in someone's dreams can hint at what they most fear losing right now.

The Night Shift: Dreams and Emotional Processing

Another well-known idea links dreaming and sleep to processing emotion. Sleep researcher Matthew Walker and colleagues pointed out that during REM sleep, levels of noradrenaline, a brain chemical tied to stress, stay low. They proposed a kind of overnight therapy: the brain revisits painful memories in a calmer chemical state, gradually drawing the sting out of the memory while keeping its content.

From this angle, a nightmare may be a night when that processing stalls, or when the feeling left over is simply too strong to file away. Frightening dreams that cluster during anxious periods or after a shock might be the mind opening and closing the same drawer again and again. For many people, the dreams fade or shift shape as time passes.

On the other hand, sometimes reliving the same scene in dreams does not soften the feeling but deepens the fear. Nightmares that replay a traumatic event almost exactly are thought to reflect a memory stuck in its raw state rather than one being processed. When dreams like these continue, it is a time to seek a specialist's help rather than trying to push through alone.

Stress, Fever, Medication, Alcohol

Stress and lack of sleep are among the most common things said to invite nightmares, and many people notice rougher dreams during worried or irregular stretches of life. Dreams during a fever are often described as distorted, repetitive and unpleasant, familiar enough that English has a name for them: fever dreams. A rise in body temperature affecting brain activity is one suggested explanation, but the details are still not well understood.

Alcohol plays a part too. A drink before bed may seem to help you fall asleep, but it is thought to suppress REM sleep early in the night and allow a rebound later as it wears off, which matches the experience of vivid dreams and waking before dawn. Some medications, including certain blood pressure drugs and antidepressants, are also known to make dreams more vivid or nightmares more frequent in some people. Never stop a medication on your own; if you are concerned, talk to the doctor or pharmacist who prescribed it.

Recurring Nightmares and How They Are Treated

An occasional nightmare is ordinary, but when similar nightmares keep returning, make you afraid to sleep or affect your daily life, doctors may describe it as nightmare disorder. Frequent nightmares are thought to affect a few percent of adults and are more common after distressing experiences. The key point is that this is not something to simply endure; it is something you can seek help for.

One well-known treatment is imagery rehearsal therapy. While awake, you rewrite the plot of a recurring nightmare however you like, then rehearse the new version in your mind each day. The American Academy of Sleep Medicine's 2018 position paper lists it as a recommended approach for nightmare disorder. Other psychological therapies and medications are also used, and what works differs from person to person. If nightmares keep troubling you, please do not carry it alone; consult a medical professional such as a sleep clinic or a mental health specialist.

Our View: Horror Lovers and Their Nightmares

In our view, the question of whether reading scary stories gives you nightmares has no clean yes or no. Many people say they had bad dreams after horror films or stories, but the effect is thought to vary a great deal from person to person. Because dreams tend to borrow from our days, a story that shakes you right before bed may well become material for the night. Yet it is hard to claim a simple rule that people who read ghost stories nightly are the ones most plagued by nightmares.

This is speculation, but people who love horror may be people who have learned to taste fear in a safe place. Close the book and it ends; turn off the screen and the room is still lit. Knowing that boundary is what lets fear become play. If threat simulation theory sees dreams as rehearsal for danger, ghost stories might be a small daytime rehearsal of their own. For generations, people have gathered around hearths and on summer nights to trade frightening tales, giving shape and names to unease they could not explain. A fear with a name is a little easier to hold than one without.

So there is one thing we would gently ask you to watch for. Our sense is that dreams grow heavy not so much from the story itself as from the moment it links up with a real worry inside you: a family member's illness, trouble at work, grief for someone lost. If the ghost from a tale starts appearing in your dreams wearing the face of your own anxiety, that may be a sign to move from enjoying stories to resting your mind. Loving fear and being hunted by it look similar but are not the same. Those who can tell the difference are, we think, the ones who truly enjoy a good scare.

A book that reads through the strange phenomena and vengeful spirits appearing in classics like the Kojiki and the Konjaku Monogatarishu — a reference for our legend and kaidan articles.

Strange Classical Literature: Japan's Beautiful World of the Uncanny (Itsuki Asazato / Asahi Shimbun Publications)

VIEW ON AMAZON VIEW ON RAKUTEN VIEW ON YAHOO!

We may earn a referral fee on purchases made through these links.

What You Can Do Tonight and Tomorrow Morning

Tonight, try to make the last hour before bed a quiet one. Read ghost stories while it is still light, go easy on alcohol, and step away from screens. Simply telling yourself that the day is done can help your mind switch over. Japan has long had customs for this: placing a picture or the written name of the baku, a mythical beast said to eat bad dreams, by the pillow, or reciting a yume-chigae charm meant to turn a bad dream into a good one. Whether or not you believe, they can serve as small rituals that settle you for the night.

Tomorrow morning, if you had a nightmare, jot it down briefly in a notebook by the bed. A dream journal lets you look at the dream from a distance and notice links to daytime worries. If the dream keeps coming back, try rewriting just the ending the way you would like it and picture it a few times. If nightmares still keep you from resting, or the tiredness follows you into the day, do not dismiss it as just a dream; please consult a medical professional. A frightening dream may be your mind trying to tell you something.

Dreams mentioned in this essay

FAQ

Q. Why do we have nightmares?
A. There is no single settled answer. Known ideas include heightened amygdala activity during REM sleep, threat simulation theory, and dreaming as emotional processing. Stress, poor sleep, fever and alcohol are also linked to more nightmares.

Q. Do horror stories or films cause nightmares?
A. A strongly upsetting experience before bed can feed into dreams, but the effect varies widely between people. If it bothers you, enjoy horror earlier in the day and keep the last hour before sleep calm.

Q. What should I do if nightmares keep happening?
A. Keeping a dream journal and rewriting the ending of a recurring nightmare can help; the latter is used clinically as imagery rehearsal therapy. If sleep becomes frightening or daily life suffers, please consult a medical professional.

Look up your own dream in the Dream Dictionary →

More dream essays

Other categories

※ Dream interpretation here is entertainment drawing on psychology and folklore — it is not scientifically proven. "This site's view" is our own interpretation. If bad dreams or poor sleep continue, please consult a medical professional.